This is the oldest WW1 AFV plastic kit by far: I guess it's soon 40 years
old. I think most of us has seen it, one time or another. But how good - or
bad - is it? Well, despite it's age it is still a fine kit. The moulds are
showing their age, and there are some ugly sink-marks to be filled in, but the
details are still sharp. For example, the rivets are wonderful - although too plentiful: see this
article by David Maynard. But there are a number of smaller problems, and
one big.
Let's start with the big one. Funnily enough, despite the boxart and
averything, the kit does not portray a Mk I, with the exception of the
tail-wheel assembly. The kit shows a Mk II!
Some
history first. After the debut of the tank in 1916, it was decided that the Mk
I needed some major redesign, and this work would eventually end up with the
much improved Mk IV. But to keep the assembly lines going it was decided that
a short series of modified Mk I:s would be produced. This modified Mk I was
called Mk II, and there were only some minor modifications: the manhole hatch
was raised somewhat, a hatch added to the drivers cab, the steering wheel
assembly was completely discarded, and the drivers cab made smaller, to
provide for trackspuds attached to every sixth link - to improve traction. After 50 of these Mk II:s had been produced, the tank was
modified again, and 50 more were produced. This was the Mk III. The armour was
increased, but otherwise the outward differences were small: a silencer was
now provided - it had also been used on late-productions Mk II:s - and on
late-productions Mk III:s a short version of the 6 pdr-gun was used on the
"Males", while the "Females" employed the same MG sponsons
as the Mk IV. (For more info on this tank,
click here! And you could also
get this excellent book.)
So there we have it: what you get in the kit is a
late-production Mk II! That is, if you discard the steering wheels. If not,
you get a hybrid that has never existed.
In general, this is a fine kit, that has aged well. There are a couple of
sink-marks here and there, but nothing disastrous.
AS
you can see on this photo, the level of detail is fine, and the details
themselves are sharp. (You can see a couple of the sink-marks on the big side
part.) You can also see a couple of the problems, at least if you are
building a Mk I: the hatch in the drivers cab, the triangular raised hatch on
the roof, and the lack of MG hatch and pistol port on the inside of the gun
sponson. In short: it's still a fine kit!
So when you build the kit, you must first decide what version it is
supposed to be! Then three things must be done, regardless if you are doing a
Mk I, a Mk II or a Mk III. Firstly, the hatch in the Drivers cab roof must be
filled in, and the sides of the cab detailed: with rivets, pistol ports and a
small sighting aperture. Secondly, the gun domes must be provided with an aperture for
the sighting apparatus, and thirdly - as mentioned - a small MG hatch must be added to the
inside of the sponsons. (See this photo.) Other
small details changes, common to all three variants, and all pretty optional,
depending on hwo picky you want to be, is to replace the kits towing hawser on
the front - it should be a sort of double construction - and perhaps adding
two driving lights on the inside front of the sponsons.
Then you make your pick! Of these Marks, the easiest to model is actually
the Mk III. The only modifications, besides the removal of the Wheeled Tail
and adding details connected to this, is the shortening of the gun. You could
also actually keep the long gun, as the short variant was only used on
late-production Mk III:s.
| |
Mk I |
Mk II
|
Mk III
|
|
Drivers
Cab Width |
Broad |
Narrow |
Narrow |
|
Steering
Wheel Assembly? |
Yes |
No |
No |
|
Roof
Hatch |
Round |
Raised |
Raised |
|
Exhaust
Arrangement |
Triangular Shields |
Triangular Shields |
Silencer |
|
Track
Spuds? |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
|
6-pdr
type |
Long |
Long |
Short |
The changes concering the drivers
cab and the new roof hatch, is evident from this plan.
And you must of course consult Hans van Oerles excellent article on correcting
the Airfix kit, which has excellent plans for everything, including the track
spuds! So what about the Wheeled Tail? Well, it must be removed if you want to make a
Mk II or III. And the holes in the sides should be filled in, while the holes in
the rear end plate must be masked off, one with a small, square plate, the other with a
box, positioned off center to the left. (See this
photo.)
If you are doing the Mk I, the
roof of the drivers cab should be given two, really thin, slightly
forward-pointing periscopes, and then you must give the Wheeled Tail a thorough
going-over. Kit part no.37 is a good basis for the job, but it's simply a bit
too crude and inaccurate as is. What needs to be done is pretty self-evident if
you study this photo.
(And here is my own Mk I "Male"
being built.)